The Hit on Browns' Josh Cribbs an Inappropriate Act of Retaliation
Written by Daniel Wolf
After reading a Bleacher Report article on how Cleveland Browns quarterback Brady Quinn should be suspended for a low blow on Baltimore Ravens defender Terrell Suggs, I had to make a stand for my Browns and write this article on how the hit on Josh Cribbs was uncalled for and Ravens defensive end Dwan Edwards should be suspended and fined for this hit.
It was the last play of the game, and Quinn threw a pass to Cribbs, who then began to run and also look for another Browns player to lateral to.
He found tight end Robert Royal, who caught the ball, but then unbeknownst to Cribbs, he was targeted by Edwards. After I watched the replay, Edwards went for Cribbs' throat and smashed his arm right into Cribbs' head, causing him to lie motionless on the field once the game was over.
Was this a retaliation play by the Ravens' Edwards because Quinn was just trying to make a play earlier in the game and went a little too low and hit Suggs' knees because he was going for the defender who picked off his pass?
I would say it is very possible knowing that the Ravens like to play very aggressively and perhaps too aggressively at times.
In Quinn's defense, he is a quarterback who normally doesn't block big defensive players on a regular basis, so even after watching the reply of his block on Suggs, I would say that he was trying to make a play to the best of his ability without trying to hurt himself or another.
On the other hand, Edwards' hit on Cribbs looked to be a direct result of him going after Cribbs and attacking his head rather than his body.
Cribbs was eventually carted off the field and he was taken to a local Cleveland hospital immediately.
No word yet on the status of Cribbs' injury, but Browns coach Eric Mangini did tell the media that Cribbs did have feeling and movement in all of his extremities.
The Ravens were successful in beating the Browns 16-0 on Monday Night Football and they were also successful in possibly ending the season of one of the Browns' best and most talented players on their roster.
As a Browns fan, my prayers go out to Cribbs for good news and to have a speedy recovery and I strongly suggest to NFL officials to throw the hammer down on Edwards and suspend him for multiple games and give him a tremendous fine for his hit.
(Thank you Sam Ingro for the following photo!)
(Article also posted on Dawg Scooper and Bleacher Report)
This is a fan-created post. Dawgs By Nature assumes no responsibility for the content listed.
63 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
is there video of this anywhere? i had a dodgeball game that seemed more exciting than watching my team get booed and beat up some more. and if quinn get fined for his hit … which from what i saw was pretty iffy on whether it was a cheap shot or not … then edwards should get fined for his.
He was also in the process of coming to a stop and not looking at the defender at all. Edwards HIneswarded it on that play.
Even if Cribbs feels OK this weekend I think they should sit him against the Lions. Why risk something more permanent in a meaningless game?
Brownsyup
It might be our last chance at a win
by TheRealSlimShady on Nov 18, 2009 11:36 PM EST up reply actions
Why not just tell him to take the rest of the season off?
by RelapsingDawgCatcher on Nov 19, 2009 12:48 AM EST up reply actions
I think it was a cheap shot. It deserved some type of penalty even if unintentional and was similar to Quinn’s block. Both had some extenuating circumstances, both had serious outcomes.
It would be a penalty in hockey so it should be a penalty here.
I don’t think we needed a personal foul call with a second to go. That would have just increased the idiocracy that was our last play. That’s probably why it wasn’t called in the first place.
That’s why Goodell hands our fines.
Author of the segment "A Brownie For Your Thoughts," on DBN. Check it out.
by SpecialBrownie on Nov 18, 2009 8:29 AM EST up reply actions
I think we´re missing the point here.
The Browns were fiery competitors till the end. That´s a winner´s trait.
Let´s make sure Brady Quinn, Josh Cribbs and Robert Royal get a star for their helmets.
As for Brady Quinn’s “hit”, I think it is hilarious that after the Pats/Ravens game all you heard was Ray Ray crying about putting skirts on QB’s because you can’t go low.
Then he calls Quinn’s hit “criminal”.
Isn’t Suggs the same player who was fined for admiting that the Ravens have bounties on opposing players?
Hey Ravens, Karma is a bitch.
by Bernie19Kosar on Nov 18, 2009 1:36 PM EST up reply actions
No.
Irony to end all ironies is if Lewis goes into politics after he retires.
Author of the segment "A Brownie For Your Thoughts," on DBN. Check it out.
by SpecialBrownie on Nov 18, 2009 9:55 PM EST up reply actions
Becoming a prosecuting lawyer?
Author of the segment "A Brownie For Your Thoughts," on DBN. Check it out.
by SpecialBrownie on Nov 18, 2009 10:12 PM EST up reply actions
LAME. FAIL.
If it was a Dirty hit, why’d “Baby Cribbs” Say himself it was perfectly fine. Sure it hurt but he didn’t say it was a cheapshot.
That is EXACTLY why. Cribbs is really the classiest NFL player. He’s not going to whine like “it’s criminal!” Lewis and “I lost a blocking battle to Brady Quinn!” Suggs.
Author of the segment "A Brownie For Your Thoughts," on DBN. Check it out.
by SpecialBrownie on Nov 19, 2009 7:38 AM EST up reply actions
With that Logic...
Anyone who thinks they got drilled for RETALIATION & says so ISNT classy? He didn’t say it was dirty because it wasn’t, not because of his class. Speaking of Class, has Cribbs signed that long term contract with “HIS TEAM”? Or is he stretching it out, so he can get as much as possible? Real class. Next thing you’ll say with that reasoning is Brett Favre was a real Class act this offseson. C’mon man.
by Fargo2Detroit on Nov 19, 2009 8:04 AM EST up reply actions
Now you question his class, then continue to mention an exact example of his class. Cribbs decided to play this season despite being grossly underpaid as an act in good faith. Are you really that stupid? It’d be like me trying to make a claim of how smart you are then mentioning your most resent comments as evidence of that. “C’mon man.”
Ahem. This is basically what F2D said.
“So Cribbs is classy because he’s playing with a bum contract he doesn’t think he deserves? But goes out on the field every Sunday and kicks ass? Way to drag it out Cribbs. A classy person sits on the sidelines and whines till he gets money he doesn’t deserve. That’s class.”
It’s been paraphrased here and there of course.
Author of the segment "A Brownie For Your Thoughts," on DBN. Check it out.
by SpecialBrownie on Nov 19, 2009 3:07 PM EST up reply actions
He plaid because he had to!
He was under contract to play. No play, No money. BTW I like Cribbs as a player. Class is sighning with Cleveland no matter how many dollar$ they offer after this year. Most players want to win. He wasn’t taking a paycut by playing, he was following contract, these guys have agents & lawyers.Even they couldn’t get him out of Clevleland.
by Fargo2Detroit on Nov 19, 2009 4:59 PM EST up reply actions
Wow! Thats so funny! I spelled wrong!
The most ironic thing ever, is ppl. bitching bout spelling on a Cleveland blog! Oh I forgot the A. About. Real LAME_____ Attack someone for typing wrong w a PS3 controller. Must be nothing else you can counter point on. FAIL.
by Fargo2Detroit on Nov 24, 2009 10:01 AM EST up reply actions
I forgot a comma, watch out word nazi's
If I lived in Cleveland I’d rather spend time correcting others than talk about any of my "teams’ too. Good game against D-town.
by Fargo2Detroit on Nov 24, 2009 10:04 AM EST up reply actions
the guy whose team went winless last year talks shit after getting their 2nd win this year over our 1-win team. interesting.
I saw the movie Gran Torino, and am pretty sure no one from Detroit should be talking smack about which place is better to live.
There’s lots of residential properties left, besides the industrial debris….
by RelapsingDawgCatcher on Nov 25, 2009 3:32 PM EST up reply actions
He already has a contract for a few more years. Why does he have to sign another one?
by TheRealSlimShady on Nov 19, 2009 5:37 PM EST up reply actions
We actually have a post about Cribbs being classy here
by TheRealSlimShady on Nov 19, 2009 5:44 PM EST up reply actions
nyone who thinks they got drilled for RETALIATION & says so ISNT classy?
I assume you meant that if we thought it was retaliation then we aren’t classy. Well, I speak for myself here, I’m not all that classy.
I’m as classy as Ray Lewis then too.
Author of the segment "A Brownie For Your Thoughts," on DBN. Check it out.
by SpecialBrownie on Nov 20, 2009 12:03 AM EST up reply actions
You come off as a complete moron. You’re going to insult a play, arguably the hardest worked player in the NFL, question his toughness, then continue to mention a statement that player made which helps prove how tough he is?
Try harder, Troll.
Because he said he was hit legally he is tough?
OK. I get it.
by Fargo2Detroit on Nov 19, 2009 5:01 PM EST up reply actions
The complicated thought process of Eric Mangini as the final seconds wind down...
I am worried about the size of my opening.
I am so huge down there.
Option #1 Just go to the market get some raw liver and stick it in your mangina.
Option #2 Run a hook and lateral, down by 16 with no time left, endangering the last remaining talent on your team.
Goodell is a huge piece of inconsistent crap.
And also Ray Lewis is now in a “player assesment” group of some sort with Tony Dungy and Kurt Warner.
Wtf??
Author of the segment "A Brownie For Your Thoughts," on DBN. Check it out.
by SpecialBrownie on Nov 19, 2009 10:57 PM EST up reply actions

by 

























