How to beat the House, NFL Edition: Intro

Nfl-logo-shields_medium
The times, they are a changin'
Every single year it seems like certain teams are good, certain teams suck.  I am not talking about the Dolphins going from 1-15 to the playoffs in one season.  I am talking about being good.  Year in and year out, this team is in the playoff hunt.  It doesn't matter what happens, we know that we are going to win at least 9 games and be playing for something on week 17.  Every year there are teams that suck.  I mean at the top of the draft every year, making horrible additions in free agency and even worse draft selections.  
It was eating at me.  Every year a handful of teams can be counted on as being in the playoff race.  Colts, Pats,SteelersEagles and Ravens.  It was pissing me off.  What did these teams know?  What did my team not?  Was it luck? (doubtful) or was it something else that I wasn't even thinking of?  I needed to know more.
I decided to do some digging.  It all started out as a discussion topic between my friends and I.  It took off.  Instead of sitting around arguing over what NBA player we could take in a fist fight (Tony Parker, in a laugher), it turned into what was making the Eagles good every year.  We had two Browns fans (my brother and myself) a Bengals fan, and a Steelers fan (every joke was a Ravens one).  
For the past two months we have been tearing down the NFL and more importantly the NFL draft.  We went into this with open minds.  Nothing was off limits.  We tested everything.  I do mean everything.  Should you take a RB early in the draft?  What is the best range to draft a QB?  Is it worth drafting a TE?  After all, what better way to learn than examine the past? 
We all agreed going in, that we needed to start over from the start.  My entire life I have heard certain rules of football.  Stop the run.  Defense wins championships.  Never take a kicker in the first round of a draft.  We forgot them all.  We needed to start with a brand new blank slate.  The reason I am stressing this is two fold.  One, when I ask stupid questions like "Did the Raiders make a mistake taking a kicker in the first round of the 2000 draft?" you grasp the fact that I am not retarded, I am just checking everything.  
Secondly, and most importantly, because we are going to need your help.  The reason I am posting these theories and ideas here is because I haven't found another place that has so many knowledgeable and educated fans in one place.  I have been on this website for years and have come to respect the knowledge of the members here as much as my closest friends.  
We are by no means done.  But I want to start testing these theories.  I am going to post these ideas and I need everyone here to look at them openly and try and find holes.  Are my levels for a player being "good" too high or too low?  Are some of my ideas just too crazy to get behind?  I am excited to get some feedback and see if these ideas hold water.  What more can I add?  What am I missing?  As of right now, I have at least three more posts planned, and I really hope to add more as I go.  
I went in with an open mind, and was blown away by many things that I have found.  My mind has been changed on certain things that I have been adamantly against in the past.
IF everything goes as planned, I hope to have my own draft board ready to go, with everything we have learned, for the opening night of the draft April 22nd.  Who knows, it may look like Mel Kiper's draft board, but I am guessing it won't be close.  Either way, it will be good for a laugh.
I don't know how many of these posts I will be able to do.  I have a butt load of data, some which really matters, most of it just the ramblings of a mad man.  I will do my best to get these all out in a thoughtful, easily readable manner.  So, if you don't mind, on to the first installment of "How to beat the House, NFL Edition."
How far do we go back in getting information?
We can all agree that the NFL has changed, but when?  That was our first problem.  How far do we look back?
Rules have changed.  Coaching philosophies have changed.  The game has changed so much that a former Super Bowl winning Head Coach, Joe Gibbs, had a losing record when he decided to return.  An offensive genius went from a 124-60 record to a 30-34 record.  Don't blame Gibbs, he had no chance. 
Blame what you want.  College's becoming passing factories in order to compete with the big boys.  Today's NFL defenses are filled with speed at every level.  Good luck running wide on LB's and DE's that run 4.5's.  
We can argue at what point in time this happened, but for myself, I put it at the season of '99.  This isn't because the Browns returned in '99, it was because of "The Greatest Show on Turf".  It was the second straight season that a passing offense was destroying the NFL (the '98 Vikings with Moss and Carter were a missed FG from a Super Bowl) and had finally punched through and won a Super Bowl.
Sn_u_vermeil_576_medium
By no means am I saying that these teams won with the passing game alone.  But these teams were using a passing attack as their main weapon.  They were using the pass to set up the run.  They were zigging when everyone else was zagging.  They had found something, they just didn't know what.
Over the following ten seasons many factors changed the NFL.  
Personally, I think that the rule changes that the NFL has enforced over the past ten years are the biggest culprit.  Quarterbacks receive Presidential-like protection from pass rushers.  Intentional grounding rules were changed so QB's could more easily avoid sacks.  Last but not least, the most influential ruling of them all; before the '04 season, the NFL instructed officials to pay special attention to illegal contact, defensive PI and defensive holding.  No longer were defenders allowed to beat the crap out of WR's and TE's.  After 5 yards, the offensive player has a hassle-free route to run.  Passing was easier in the todays NFL.  
Here is the best example I can give you, see if you can guess the two QB's:
Player A:  59.0 Cmp%, 22-10 TD-INT Ratio, 7.9 YPA
Player B: 62.1 Cmp%, 21-12 TD-INT Ratio, 7.0 YPA
Outside of the higher YPA (7.9 is very good, while 7.0 is good, but not great), the stat lines look very similar.  Both of these players played their home games in the same stadium.  One of these QB's was considered one of the greatest of all-time and won a Super Bowl in the season mentioned above and also played in that seasons Pro Bowl.  The other is considered re-tread and nothing more than a replaceable QB.  Give up?
Player A is John Elway in the '98 season.  Player B is Kyle Orton this past season.  By no means am I saying that Orton sucks.  In fact, I think Orton had a very good season.  But in ten years a season like the one Orton just had went from being good enough for the Pro Bowl and Super Bowl to not even being good enough to be the 7th alternate in the '09 Pro Bowl.  
Ten seasons.  Ten seasons of drafts, stats and results to look over.  What was making these teams good?  What was making teams bad?  
The Three B's.
We have looked at the bad teams and the good teams.  Many different factors lead to a team being good or bad, but every reason we could think of fell into these three categories (in no particular order).
  1. Bad Leadership****CHANGED****:  Teams that consistently make poor decisions.  Whether it be hiring a coach with a poor track record, or picking in the draft poorly on a consistent basis.  Take the Bills for example, they just fired a coach who had one winning seasons in the 10 years he was a NFL coach and replaced him with a HC who hasn't been a NFL coach in 11 seasons (remember how Gibbs fared when he came back?) and lead Georgia Tech to better than a 7-5 record once in 6 seasons!  Does anyone expect the Chan Gailey tour to work in Buffalo?  Anyone?  This is a great example of poor leadership.  Other franchises can swap out HC's and keep winning (Pittsburgh) because of good leadership.
  2. Bad Contracts:  This is by far the biggest issue.  Teams have a limited resource (money under the cap) yet they use the money in stupid ways.  Take the Raiders and Gibril Wilson.  Not only do they sign a completely replaceable safety to a nearly 40 million dollar deal, they cut him the following season.  That contract stays.  Bad contracts=bad teams more than anything else I looked at.  Good players can have bad contracts (think Kellen Winslow in Tampa or Reggie Bush in New Orleans).
  3. Bad Luck:  This is the only thing on this list that a team cannot control.  Every team will encounter this.  Good teams overcome it.  Bad teams crumble.  It happens every season.
It bothers me when someone says a team sucks because a coach is doing a poor job.  That category is not a catch all.  I am talking about a team that either has zero leadership and direction (think the Bills under Jauron) or have the talent to succeed yet somehow always end up in extended losing streaks and falling below expectations (Cowboys before this season).  
Bad contracts are ten times more important, and dangerous, than coaching.  Bad contracts can kill a team in one off-season (think Browns of '07-'08).  This is the category in which we have done the most work on so far.  Bad drafting leads to bad contracts, which leads to bad football teams.  Sometimes it is just that easy.
Now you know
The reason I explained everything is so you can get an idea of what I am trying to do here.  Now I need you, the reader, to try and tear this apart.  In a friendly way.  I need input from you.  I want opinions on how to tweak things.  I, with help from others, have created formulas for many different things; from how to evaluate a QB, to what should be the highest amount we should be able to offer rookies.  I am still trying to figure out the best way to gauge RB's and WR's.  Any ideas and thoughts are welcomed and expected.
First a couple of rules.  
  1. The Colts are thrown out.  They do everything wrong, according to us, yet somehow win.  I mean EVERYTHING.  This is because of one reason.  Peyton Manning.  This isn't just sour grapes.  Peyton Manning is an outlier.  He is on another plane all by himself.  No other team, and I mean every single team we looked at, was successful following the Colts lead.  Going into this, I always considered Manning the best QB of my time.  After this, I now consider Peyton Manning the greatest football player to ever play.  That's how far the numbers are skewed by him.  As of right now he is already the highest ranking QB in our study.  We are talking about a formula that includes longevity yet he has 5-6 years to put even more distance between him and the field.  My respect for Peyton Manning went up about 10 fold in the past two months.  Building a football team in the mold of the Indianapolis Colts should be franchise suicide.  In fact, we believe part of the reason that the Colts had trouble winning under Manning in the early-mid '00s was their asinine roster construction and drafting.  At some point in time, Peyton just became too freaking good to let this matter and the Colts haven't looked back.  Peyton Manning has become self aware and he will end up killing all of man kind.
  2. Everything I have done, and will do, can change.  There have been ideas and thoughts that I have had that I could not convince myself that maybe, just maybe I was wrong.  No longer.  Open mind.  Remember this when I try and explain something that sounds totally foreign to you, because trust me, I will.  Consider it a rebirth of football.  Without all the crying.
  3. I am willing to explain anything and everything that I put out.  If something doesn't make sense, ask me and I will do my best to explain how I got there.  I will not be right in every aspect, this is the only thing that I am sure of.  After all, this is the brain child of three guys who spend the majority of their free time drinking beer, arguing over who is the greatest playmate, and whether or not we as a group could defeat Hulk Hogan in a 3 on 1 match (no freaking doubt).  We are not MENSA members.  Challenge us.
  4. Have fun with this, because I have.
You will be shocked to see what I have found.  The NFL has changed, NFL teams need to do the same.
We can no longer draft by the old set of rules.  We need new ones.  Why are we drafting certain positions in the first round even though the numbers show that it is a foolish choice?  We are talking about smart people making stupid moves.  I am here to try and change this, but I am going to need some help.  

Next Post: Where is the best value of the NFL draft?

X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Dawgs By Nature

You must be a member of Dawgs By Nature to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Dawgs By Nature. You should read them.

Join Dawgs By Nature

You must be a member of Dawgs By Nature to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Dawgs By Nature. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9341_tracker