Dawgs By Nature: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Jeff Sullivan's MLB Trade Deadline Primer

The Offseason Has Begun

And...I'm Back.

Last season, I reviewed the finale between the Cleveland Browns and the Houston Texans on the same night the game occurred. Why was I able to post so quickly after the season had ended? Because I had already been braced for the end of the season. Several weeks prior to that final game of the season, it was confirmed that the Browns were eliminated from postseason contention. That wasn't the case this season.

After winning on Sunday, I was ready to watch the game that had prevented me from sleeping the night before out of anticipation: the Tennessee Titans vs. the Indianapolis Colts. When the kickoff was about to start, I was shaking. Throughout the entire game, I was shaking. When the game ended...everything was over. No, life wasn't over (because after all, it's still "just" a game). However, something I look forward to every Sunday during the regular season, especially in a winning season, felt like it ended prematurely.

I thought to myself, "how can I possibly feel like giving my assessment of the Browns/49ers game when in essence it really didn't mean a damn thing?" There were a lot of other things I could've posted about the following morning.

I could've posted on Monday and blamed Reggie Wayne for fumbling on the Colts' first offensive drive of the game.
I could've posted on Monday and blamed Jim Sorgi for being a terrible backup quarterback.
I could've posted on Monday and blamed the freakish fact that a more pure quarterback, Kerry Collins, was the reason the Titans won.
I could've posted on Monday and blamed the coin toss for going the Titans' way.
I could've posted on Monday and blamed Tony Dungy for not taking a timeout with about 20 seconds left in the game.

Instead, I decided not to post at all.

Was it because I was bitter?

I wanted to wait a few days until I was back in brighter spirits to better collect my thoughts. When I woke up on Monday, I went back to sleep, because the only thing I could think about was the game I just watched before heading to sleep Sunday night. Things were better Tuesday as I brought in the new year, and here I am today, back and ready to bring you all of the Browns coverage you've come to know and love from this site.

I must, however, still address one of the things I "could've posted on Monday", and that involved Dungy. It was inexcusable for him not to use a timeout towards the end of the game. If you don't want to risk injuries to your starters, I understand that. But when you have your backups in the game, you still need to protect the integrity of the game. Did the potential exist for the Colts to block a potential Rob Bironas field goal and return it for a touchdown? Yes. Did the potential exist for the Titans to go for it on fourth down, not make it, and then have Sorgi heave a miracle play? Yes. Instead, Dungy jogged to mid-field with a stupid little grin on his face as he congratulated a division rival for making it into the postseason.

The NFL has a rule saying teams must make a "bona-fide effort" to win, even if the game has no impact on the standings. The Giants surely honored that rule by going all-out against the Patriots, although Jersey/A already had locked into its seeding; the Giants' all-out effort was extremely impressive, and bodes well for their postseason. Most season-finale games don't matter, so no one cares about the bona fide effort rule. But Indianapolis, which also had locked up its seed already, did not make a bona fide effort to defeat Tennessee -- Peyton Manning played two series; starters sat out the second half -- and Tony Dungy's decision to field his practice squad had the effect of keeping Cleveland out of the postseason. There's no conspiracy here since Indianapolis, as the second seed, couldn't play the sixth seed (whether Tennessee or Cleveland) before the AFC championship and the sixth seed reaching the championship is unlikely. Still, the rule stipulates that NFL teams must try to win, and, in a consequential game, Indianapolis did not try to win.

Cleveland has a grievance -- and the football gods might wax wroth against the Colts. (Dallas did not try to beat Washington, either, but as Minnesota and New Orleans both lost, neither can complain about the Cowboys.)
-Gregg Easterbrook, ESPN Page 2

With that said, the Colts have been my favorite team in football besides the Browns the past several years. And, the Colts are still my next favorite team in football. Something did change as a result of Dungy's decision, and it'll come next season, starting when the league releases the schedules for the 2008-2009 season. We already know that the Browns will be facing the Colts in Cleveland. I'm going to circle that date on my calendar. It won't be a large as the circle I draw for the Steelers, but it'll be significant enough to where every time I see it, I'll remember the timeout that Dungy didn't take.

Hopefully the Browns have a tremendous offseason, enough to the point where they win the AFC North and don't have to play the starters in Week 17. Who would be nice to face in Week 17? I don't know; maybe the Colts? Maybe, just maybe, the Colts and Jaguars will be more neck-and-neck for the division lead next season. If the Browns win, the Jaguars get the division. If the Colts win, they get the division. Surely, with the division wrapped up, we could sit Braylon Edwards and Kellen Winslow after the first quarter, right? Or, take Derek Anderson (or Brady Quinn) out and feed Ken Dorsey to the wolves? Not a chance. I'd want to see our starters go four quarters and upset the Colts. Then, when our quarterback takes a knee when the Colts are all out of timeouts, I'd laugh as I watch Romeo Crennel jog onto the field with a Belichick-like fist-pump.

No, I'm not bitter. I'm just hungry for more.

0 recs  |  Comment 29 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Chris,
First off, thanks for the great coverage this season.  I'm already looking forward to hanging out here next season.

I also agree on Indy next season, it will have some interesting subplots when they visit next year, whenever it is.

by CraigD on Jan 2, 2008 11:30 PM EST reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Chris,

No offense, but as pathetic as Sorgi was, IND could have had the ball inside TEN's 10 ytd line with 2:00 min remaining and still not sniffed the goal line.

A timeout with 20 seconds would have made about as much difference as duct tape during Katrina.

by rickyfeacher on Jan 4, 2008 8:10 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Instead of blaming the Colts for us not being the playoffs, maybe someone should have made DA aware of this rule before the Bengals game.
"The NFL has a rule saying teams must make a "bona-fide effort" to win..."

Could the Colts have done more?  Absolutely.  Is it their fault the Browns are sitting at home watching the playoffs instead of playing in them?  Absolutely not.  Believe it or not, it's the Browns' fault.  We easily could have won against the Ravens, Cardinals, or Bengals to secure a spot.  It's that simple.

by misterbaseball99 on Jan 3, 2008 9:06 AM EST reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
I can't say I agree with this. You could say all the Browns had to do was win every game and they would have made the postseason which is true, but it diminishes the accomplishments of winning 10 games in the NFL. We had the same record as Tennessee, we lost on a tiebreaker. We lost a game to the Raiders after making a winning field goal that was negated by a late timeout, and we lost a game to the Cardinals on an incorrect call that should have allowed us the game winning touchdown. That there is 12 wins, and you could say all the officials had to do was make the correct decision and the Browns would have been hosting a game in Cleveland this weekend. To blame the Browns for "only: winning 10 games and not questioning the integrity of a a team laying down in the final and the most important week of the season (most important because the final outcome is decided for fringe playoff teams) is not really fair to the team.

by Roger Dorn on Jan 3, 2008 10:48 AM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
You're looking to blame anyone but the actual team for not making the playoffs.  Last I checked, the Colts are not responsible for getting Cleveland to the post-season.  

Now don't get me wrong, I think the Browns had a very good season.  I sure didn't expect 10 wins, but I'm glad we got them.  And I think that had we made the playoffs, we could have made some noise.  

All that said, let's quit blaming officials and other teams' coaches for not being in the playoffs.  Derrick Anderson crapped in his pants in the one game that could have decided the fate of the team in week 16.  It was laid out in black and white.  Beat the Bengals = go to the playoffs.  Tony Dungy didn't throw 4 INTs in that game.  The officials didn't sandbag us in that game.  Lane Kiffin didn't screw us in that game.  Our QB laid a turd on the field for all to see.  

Why should the Colts give 2 shits whether the Browns make the playoffs or not?  In fact, do you suppose it's possible they decided they'd rather face the Titans down the road than the Browns?  I'm not saying they blatantly threw the game in a Black Sox-esque scandal like some here seem to think.  But their main concern is to look out for their own ass.  

As for citing a rule that every team is obligated to put forth an effort to win the game, then every single game as season winds down that a team sits its starters could be considered as violating this rule.  Nobody has ever made such a stink about it before.  But now it effects our team and we think we are owed something by the Colts.  I don't like that argument.  I think, and I'm sure Browns players would agree, that the only team responsible for getting the Browns in the playoffs is the Browns.  

by misterbaseball99 on Jan 3, 2008 11:14 AM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
The Steelers to us are supposed to be the Colts to the Titans in terms of getting "owned". We got our two losses to the Steelers. The Titans were almost only given one loss rather than two by default.

I don't blame Dungy for resting his starters -- play whoever you want to play. However, when the game DOES mean a lot to us, whether it was our fault or not, I expect that Dungy should remain consistent. The Colts tried to win that game throughout with the guys they had. Their backup defenders are pretty good, while their backup offensive players aren't. I didn't have a problem with the Colts up until Dungy failed to take a time out. That'd tick me off as a Colts fan, Browns fan, general fan, and any type of fan with the exception of a Titans fan.

by Chris Pokorny on Jan 3, 2008 11:21 AM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Ok, Tony Dungy didn't take a time out.  And the system is kind of crappy because we get left out in the cold for a team with an identical record.  But I still think you go a bit too far when you place so much blame on Dungy or the system.  I guess if you want to be pissed at Dungy for not doing what you think would have shown more effort, fine.  But I don't think not calling a time out violates any rules of the NFL.

by misterbaseball99 on Jan 3, 2008 12:18 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
As much as I hate to say this, because I'm a Browns fan born in '64 (like a Blow Sox fan claiming to bleed red like the stains on Curt Schilling's tube sox...), the Browns had their chance to take care of business twice in December and couldn't get it done.

December is when pro football teams show what they're made of.  It's like the "dog days of August" for baseball fans.

As much as the rumors about the fix on the Colts/Titans game reeks to high heaven - the ultimate margin of victory was 6 points in the Titans' favor and the spot was exactly 6 points the same way... - That game was NOT the reason that the Browns are not in the playoffs.

The Browns' game time execution as a team in the stretch was the reason they are not in the playoffs.  Every player on the field, and every member of the coaching staff on the field and in the press box, had something to do with it.

Everybody involved with the Browns' game day execution - players and coaches alike -  can point to at least one critical play and come away from the tape thinking to himself "I should have done (this) differently and better".  One play in either the road game at Arizona or the road game in Cincinnati, on a critical point in the game, could have made the difference.

I'm not saying this to hate, or to say that the Browns should have been in the playoffs instead of Houston... umm, I meant to say the Titans.  At the same time, saying "coulda, shoulda, woulda" is as meaningless as the failure of the offensive play calling to execute in Arizona, or the failure to prevent turnovers at the end of the first half in Cincinnati.

Chud's done a great job this year, but he is not blameless... Derek Anderson has come a long way this year, but he is not blameless, either...K2 and Braylon both proved that they are worthy of being top of the first-round picks, but they can both point to catchable passes in the Arizona and Cincinnati games that would have put the team over the top in the game and into the playoffs...

To continue, RAC and the brain trust can look at clock managament and work the time outs and / or challenges better... better managament might have saved one of the games in question.  The defense was underrated and heroic in December and even before, but saving -one- game at any point in the season would have also got the team there in and of itself.

I repeat, the result of the Colts/Titans game at the end of the season is not why Cleveland is not in the playoffs.

No amount of whining at the week 17 results or accusations of collusion between Jeff Fisher and Tony Dungy will change this fact.  The Head Coach has to manage the game, the Coordinators - Offensive and Defensive) have to coach, and the players have to execute.  Without results, nobody is ready for the next step up.

Verse: The fire man screams, and the engine just gleams... Chorus: "There's a gleam, men, there's a gleam... Let's get the gleam!"

by Casey Jones on Jan 4, 2008 2:46 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
The difference is that I am viewing every regular season game as equal and not blaming one particular loss or Browns performance for not making the playoffs. If you view every game as an equal, we had an IDENTICAL record to the Titans, we lost on a third tier tiebreaker that has a number of flaws.

After thinking about this some, the only way to help avoid a problem like this in which conference record can dictate a tiebreak is to have AFC teams play only NFC teams in the last week of the season. That way it mitigates the chance of conference record and common opponents record being affected (fewer total games against NFC teams.)

by Roger Dorn on Jan 3, 2008 11:29 AM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
That's a very good idea for eliminating some problems with the later tie-breakers, but I imagine the NFL wants some opportunities for some head-to-head "win and in" matchups.

by JulioBernazard on Jan 3, 2008 2:48 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Also want to add that of course we don't care until it affects our team. It is not our duty to complain about every injustice that happens in the NFL mainly because we probably don't notice. Once it happens though you realize the flaws in the system and you want it corrected.

by Roger Dorn on Jan 3, 2008 11:34 AM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
The only problem is that it will always be a flawed system until the NFL gets to a 31 week balanced schedule in the 32 team league.
Verse: The fire man screams, and the engine just gleams... Chorus: "There's a gleam, men, there's a gleam... Let's get the gleam!"

by Casey Jones on Jan 4, 2008 2:50 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Although it's not the Colt's fault that we didn't make it, I, like Chris, am angry about the lack of effort Dungy put into winning that game.  I'll chalk this up to bitterness, but rooting against the Colts as opposed to the Pats will be my favorite thing to do in the postseason.
All being said, the Cleveland Browns are back, and heading in a direction we have been waiting for since the late 80s.  
I am looking fwd to that April date when NFL schedules are released, that's when we will find out who we are playing at home on Sunday or Monday Night Football.
Great stuff all season Chris, I'll be checking back periodically.
Go Browns!

by dawginphilly on Jan 3, 2008 10:50 AM EST reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
I am expecting us to get one Sunday Night and one Monday Night game (just based on how they do schedules in the past in relation to teams' wins/popularity). However, I wouldn't be surprised if they made our Sunday Night game later in the season so that it could be flexed out if we blew.

by Chris Pokorny on Jan 3, 2008 11:23 AM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Yeah, I'm with you on this. I think the Browns will be on prime time twice in '08, once at home and once on the road.  One Sunday night and one time on MNF - unless the later scheduled of the games is moved away from prime time on flex scheduling.

As an aside, I will have a very tough time rooting for anything in this postseason...

I will never root for the Pi**burgh team, and I can't bring myself to root for the team from the Blow Sox city (even with the obvious ties that the head coach has to our fair city... cue in the WHK 1420 Pat McCabe music from Wedding Bell Blues "I love you Bill, I always will..."), and now any rooting interest in Indiana's team is shot out of the water like shooting fish in a barrel.  I'll root for anyone to turn the big 4 (including San Diego) out from the playoffs.  Here's to competitive balance!  Prosit! ak

Verse: The fire man screams, and the engine just gleams... Chorus: "There's a gleam, men, there's a gleam... Let's get the gleam!"

by Casey Jones on Jan 4, 2008 3:22 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Also some interesting comments from Kerry Collins on WFAN this morning.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/22487240/

by Roger Dorn on Jan 3, 2008 11:40 AM EST reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Ok, now this totally changes my perspective if it's true.  Not calling a time out doesn't violate rules, but having a verbal agreement with the opposing team is taking things overboard.  Maybe the NFL should investigate.

"If true, the Cleveland Browns could possibly file a grievance alleging collusion, which is against NFL rules. The Browns would have made the playoffs if the Titans had lost."

I hope it happens.  Would love to see the result of this.  The Colts should have known better.

by misterbaseball99 on Jan 3, 2008 12:21 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
The plot thickens, as the Colts forfeit and the Browns make the playoffs ;) j/k, of course, but it'll be interesting to see if a grievance is indeed filed.

by Chris Pokorny on Jan 3, 2008 1:16 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
I hope they do file that grievance.  This is nothing short of a conspiracy.  

by misterbaseball99 on Jan 3, 2008 1:23 PM EST reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
At this point, the Browns shouldn't even bother with a grievance.  Leaving their playoff fate in the hands of Tony Dungy was their own mistake and it's all over and done with.  Like Chris said, let's save the payback for next season.

by dawgpounddaily on Jan 3, 2008 1:49 PM EST reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
i actually like the offseason here. It is filled with rumors and exciting thoughts for the future.

by kjc on Jan 3, 2008 2:19 PM EST reply actions  

One Key Point
I agree that the Browns, and especially Derek Anderson, have to look at themselves for the losses to Oakland, Arizona and Cincinnati, but the statement that "the Browns only have themselves to blame" overlooks one key point.

That one key point is that in all sixteen games, the Browns faced an opponent that was trying to win the game; the Titans did not.

by JamesPowell on Jan 3, 2008 4:09 PM EST reply actions  

Re: One Key Point
Complete bullshit.  

The Browns had by your own admission one game shy of 25% of the season to take care of the situation.  THREE OF 16 GAMES IN A SEASON THAT LASTS FROM AUGUST UNTIL THE END OF DECEMBER...

As fortunate as a season that it turned out to be, Cleveland had multiple opportunities to get the job done.  Instead the Browns chose to give someone else the opportunity to "get the fix in".

Don't get me wrong, the fix stinks like sleeping with the fishes.  

At the same time, don't complain that you're naked and cold when you burned and threw away all your clothes.

Verse: The fire man screams, and the engine just gleams... Chorus: "There's a gleam, men, there's a gleam... Let's get the gleam!"

by Casey Jones on Jan 4, 2008 3:35 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: One Key Point
It's really just unlucky scheduling. What makes the Titans 10 wins more deserving than the Browns? Because they won their last game? That is what people imply when they say the Browns didn't get it done. I'm going to argue a loss to a 7-9 Bengals team is really not all that bad, it's unfortunate that people want to highlight this game so much as if it carries so much more weight than every other regular season game.

by Roger Dorn on Jan 5, 2008 2:04 PM EST up reply actions  

Re: One Key Point
They lost when they KNEW if they won at CIN they were in. It was essentially a mini-playoff game, and they played poorly. It is a bad loss in that regard.

by JulioBernazard on Jan 7, 2008 8:27 AM EST up reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
I blame the schedule makers.  If the Titans played the Colts in Week 10 instead of week 16 and the browns played the Steelers in Week 16 instead of week 10. Then, most likely Browns are in the playoffs and the Titans are at home.

by kedda13 on Jan 4, 2008 8:13 AM EST reply actions  

Re: The Offseason Has Begun
Chris,
Thanx for the great coverage this year. I look forward to participating again next year.

Namaste.

DP

by oddjobdrummer on Jan 4, 2008 11:29 AM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Non-stop coverage of the team with the best fans in the NFL, the Cleveland Browns.

Community Guidelines
Send us a Scoop

Start posting about the Browns »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Being-manny_small
Signing Out

Recent FanPosts

Pryor_small
Early AFC North predictions
Jaden_liz_me_small
harrison vs hardesty=hmmmm
Parents_weekend__sept
Interview with C.J. Mosley
Angrydog_small
Ramblings from a storied idiot....
789canon_061_small
One Website's Uplifting Preview of the AFC North....and My Predictions...
Chrishanburgerlegends_small
Cleveland Rocks And LeBron James Career In Hollywood Has Ended
11031_act_small
Rule of 26-27-60 as a tool to determine QB success rate?
Pg2_g_aldavis5_200_small
volunteers
Small
Wide Receivers

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Browns Links

Local Media Sources
Official Browns Site
Orange and Brown Report
Cleveland Plain Dealer
Akron Beacon Journal

Browns Communities/Blogs
The Watercooler
Waiting for Next Year
Dawg Scooper
Dawg Talkers
Dawg Bones
The Browns Board

free hit counter javascript

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Washington Redskins defensive tackle Albert Haynesworth signs autographs during the NFL football team's training camp and fan appreciation day, Saturday, Aug. 8, 2009, at Redskins Park in Ashburn, Va. (AP Photo/Nick Wass) +2 updates

NFL Training Camps News: Albert Haynesworth Fails Conditioning Test

Photo +8 updates

Free Agent OT Flozell Adams Has Four Standing Offers, Seeking $4 Million

Photo

2010 NFL Preview, Buffalo Bills: Chan Gailey Takes The Reins

More from SBNation.com >


Executive Editor

Dbn_small Chris Pokorny

Minions

Awesomeness_small Bernie19Kosar

Dsc00156_small Ryan Kelsey

Rufiohookgrin01_small rufio

Moderators

Pryor_small Buckeye Brad